Chronic Pain: Why Hurt Doesn't Always Mean Harm, and How Physio Helps

Chronic pain is pain that lasts longer than 3 months. The most important thing to understand about it is that the amount of pain you feel is no longer a reliable measure of damage. Over time, the nervous system can become more sensitive, so it keeps sounding the alarm even after tissues have healed. That's why NICE guidance for chronic primary pain puts exercise and psychological approaches first, and advises against starting most painkillers. Physiotherapy helps by building activity back up safely and helping you make sense of your pain.

Key takeaways

  • Hurt doesn't always mean harm. In persistent pain, a sensitised nervous system can amplify pain signals, so pain is a poor guide to damage.
  • NICE (2021) recommends supervised group exercise and staying active for chronic primary pain, and considering CBT or ACT (talking therapies for pain).
  • NICE advises not to start paracetamol, anti-inflammatories, opioids and several other medicines for chronic primary pain, and not to offer TENS, ultrasound or interferential therapy.
  • Pain education helps most when it's combined with exercise and movement, rather than given on its own.
  • Progress is usually measured in doing more, not just in lower pain scores.

Why does pain become chronic?

Pain is your body's protection system. When you sprain an ankle, pain makes you limp, which protects the tissue while it heals. Normally the pain fades as healing happens.

In chronic pain, the alarm system itself becomes more sensitive. Nerves in the spinal cord and brain amplify signals, so ordinary movement or light pressure can hurt more than it should. Stress, poor sleep, worry about damage, low mood and inactivity can all turn the volume up further.

What turns chronic pain up or down: poor sleep, stress and avoiding movement turn it up; gradual activity, understanding pain and good sleep turn it down
What turns the pain "volume" up or down. Illustration, not data.

This doesn't mean the pain is "in your head". The pain is real. But it means the size of the pain isn't a measure of how much damage there is, and that changes how we treat it.

The myth: "If it hurts, I must be doing damage, so I should rest"

It's a natural belief, and in the first days after an injury it can be sensible. In persistent pain it usually backfires. Avoiding movement leads to weaker muscles, stiffer joints, worse sleep and more worry, which can all make the nervous system more sensitive, not less.

The research supports gradually building activity instead:

  • NICE guidance (NG193, 2021) recommends offering a supervised group exercise programme for chronic primary pain, taking people's needs and abilities into account, and encouraging people to stay physically active for longer-term health.
  • A 2021 Cochrane review of 249 trials found moderate-certainty evidence that exercise reduces pain in chronic low back pain compared with no treatment, usual care or placebo. The improvement in function was smaller.

Reading this critically: exercise helps, but the effects in trials are modest on average, and many studies were at risk of bias because you can't blind someone to doing exercise. It's not a cure, but it's one of the few treatments with consistent evidence and few side effects.

What does NICE recommend for chronic primary pain?

"Chronic primary pain" means pain that isn't better explained by another condition, such as fibromyalgia or many cases of persistent back pain. NICE's 2021 guideline is notable for how much it advises against.

NICE NG193 chronic primary pain summary: exercise recommended; CBT, ACT and acupuncture considered; don't start paracetamol, NSAIDs or opioids; don't offer TENS or ultrasound
What NICE recommends for chronic primary pain. Source: NICE NG193, 2021.
NICE recommends or suggests consideringNICE advises against
Supervised group exercise programmesStarting paracetamol, anti-inflammatories (NSAIDs) or opioids
Staying physically activeStarting gabapentinoids, benzodiazepines and several other drugs
CBT or ACT (talking therapies for pain)TENS, ultrasound and interferential therapy
A single short course of acupuncture or dry needling, under set conditionsBiofeedback
Some antidepressants, which may help pain, sleep and quality of life even without depression

This doesn't mean you must stop medicines you already take: talk to your GP before changing anything. And these recommendations are for chronic primary pain. Pain caused by another condition, such as arthritis, may be managed differently.

Does understanding pain help?

Pain neuroscience education means learning how pain works, including why hurt doesn't always mean harm. A 2019 review of 12 trials (755 people) found that, on its own, it produced only small improvements in pain and disability, with a bigger effect on catastrophising (expecting the worst about pain). People valued being able to tell their own story and having their pain explained.

What this means: understanding your pain is a useful foundation, but it works best alongside exercise and gradually returning to activity, not as a stand-alone fix.

How physiotherapy helps with chronic pain

A good physio programme for chronic pain usually includes:

  1. A thorough assessment to rule out anything that needs medical attention, and to understand how pain affects your life, sleep, work and mood.
  2. A clear explanation of what's going on, in plain language.
  3. A graded exercise plan that starts at a level you can manage on a bad day and builds up gradually.
  4. Pacing and flare-up planning, so a bad day doesn't undo weeks of progress.
  5. Goals that matter to you, such as walking to work, playing with your kids or returning to the gym.
Four steps of a physiotherapy programme for chronic pain: assess, explain, find your baseline, and build gradually
How a physio programme for chronic pain is built. Illustration, not data.

A simple starting rule: choose an activity level you can manage even on a bad day, then increase it by a small amount every week or two. Some extra discomfort is normal and not a sign of damage, as long as it settles back to your usual level within a day or so.

For a practical, step-by-step plan for living with persistent pain, see our guide to managing chronic pain day to day.

When to see a GP or get urgent help

Chronic pain should be assessed at least once to rule out other causes. See your GP promptly if you have:

  • unexplained weight loss, fever or night sweats
  • pain that's constant and getting worse, especially at night
  • a history of cancer
  • new weakness, numbness or pins and needles

Call 999 or go to A&E if back pain comes with numbness around your genitals or bottom, or new problems controlling your bladder or bowels.

If pain is affecting your mood and you're struggling to cope, talk to your GP. If you ever feel unable to keep yourself safe, call 999 or contact NHS 111.

Chronic pain physio at Athos Physio

Our clinic is inside F45 Training Studio at 77 Piccadilly in Manchester city centre. We'll take time to understand your pain, explain it clearly, and build a custom rehab and strengthening plan that starts where you are. If you find travelling difficult, we also offer home visits. You don't need a GP referral, and we work with Bupa, WPA, Vitality and Aviva. Book an appointment, or read about our approach to active rehabilitation.

FAQs

Can physiotherapy help chronic pain?
Yes, for many people. Exercise-based physiotherapy is one of the few treatments for chronic pain with consistent evidence, and NICE recommends exercise programmes for chronic primary pain. The aim is usually to help you do more and feel more in control, with pain improving alongside.

Is it safe to exercise with chronic pain?
Usually, yes. Some extra discomfort during or after exercise is common and doesn't mean you're causing damage. Start at a level you can manage on a bad day and build up gradually. Your physio will check for any reasons to be more careful.

Why does chronic pain get worse with stress?
Stress, poor sleep and worry make the nervous system more sensitive, which turns up the "volume" of pain. That's why sleep, stress management and psychological approaches like CBT or ACT can help alongside exercise.

Does chronic pain ever go away?
For some people it resolves, and for many others it becomes much more manageable. Even when pain doesn't disappear completely, people often get back to the activities that matter to them with the right plan.

This article is general information, not a substitute for an individual assessment.

Sources

Related: Managing chronic pain day to day · Active rehabilitation · Lower back pain · Passive vs active rehab · All conditions we treat

Written by Nick Chatziviltsos, PgDip, HCPC-registered physiotherapist (PH114351).

Previous
Previous

Does Bad Posture Cause Desk Pain? What the Research Actually Says

Next
Next

Physio on Health Insurance: What’s Covered, What Isn’t, and How to Claim